You will find lots of info and answers from our experienced attorneys at Albertson & Davidson. Explaining California Prop 13 Transfer Rules and Reassessment Triggers. All charts, figures, and graphs are for illustrative purposes only. And, if Mom and Dads primary residence has increased in value by over a million, it just got more expensive for Kate to own the home. Property taxes are due annually when you own a piece of real property (land/building) and are generally based on the assessed value of your property at the time you bought it, plus adjustments for inflation. To subscribe, enter your email address below. From now on, parent to child exclusions for reassessment has been limited to only the primary residence. There would be no income taxes due on this transfer, however, this would use part of the amount you are able to give without federal estate taxes (currently $11.7 million/person). Privacy Policy. Each time the property is sold or transferred the property's value is reassessed and adjusted to the new purchase price or appraised value - unless it's inherited by a child or grandchild. "@type": "Product", }, Also, the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act changed the estate and gift tax regime by increasing the amount of assets an individual may pass to their heirs tax-free. If this did not occur, then the . Not only helping seniors and homeowners over 55, Prop 13 and now Proposition 19 also help middle class families of all types, and really all sorts of CA homeowners, such as veterans, folks living on Social Security, and all sorts of retirees living on a modest fixed income like retired postal workers and other government workers, retired middle income white collar office workers and other homeowners living on a modest pension, so on and so forth. You children might be subject to higher property taxes if they keep the home. Even though there's $3,000,000 of appreciation in value (between the $200,000 original tax basis and the $3,200,000 sale), the value gets stepped-up to market value when you pass away. If no children wish to live in the parents primary residence, that child, or children will have to bear the burden of paying property taxes based on todays market value. The parent-to-child exclusion must be filed within three years of the decedents date of death. Learn more with Velasco Law Group. It depends on a myriad of personal and financial factors. Personal Capital Advisors Corporation is a registered investment advisor with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Prior to Proposition 19, parents could transfer property to their children without triggering a reassessment. In California, an estate worth at least $184,500 must, by law, open a probate case with the court, according to California inheritance laws. inheriting a house in california prop 19. inheriting a house in california prop 19frankie ryan city on a hill dead. It became essential, especially for middle class and upper middle class families, to . Investing involves risk. As you can see, there are many things to consider when thinking about your California property. As part of the measure, children who inherit their parents' houses no longer receive a property tax break if they sell real property, intend to keep it as a second home, or rent it out. Here are some additional things you should know. The advantage to inheriting property from parents is that the original purchase price (100k in the above example) is increased to reflect the current market value on the death of the homeowner. They can decide to later rent the home or move in subject of course to any conditions of the prior agreement or trust that was originally established. Terms of Use and Point Loma Location Theres even a chance this change could be retroactive to January 1, 2021. , Advisory services are offered for a fee by Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Personal Capital Corporation. By signing up, you agree to our The only way for the child to avoid this unfavorable . $50,000 (this is known as the Carryover basis). To address those issues - and at the urging of realtors who stand to gain a lot here - the California legislature put Proposition 19 on this year's ballot. Plus, they dont especially like dealing with trusts, although they will if all the elements fit perfectly. . 7 Steps You Can Take, What to Do When a Loved one Passes Away in CA without a Trust, What every Administrator Should know when Filing for probate in California. When your child sells the house shortly after, he/she will pay. If you give your child your house during your lifetime, he/she will get your home with the same cost basis as you purchased the home. 19 will reduce or eliminate some generous tax breaks that families get when property is transferred between parents and children. Our dedication to quality legal advice and representation, respect, and trust are the foundation of our business and our relationship with clients. In 1978 Proposition 13 was passed in California, largely due to concerns that soaring property values were affecting significant increases in property taxes. Past performance is not a guarantee or indicative of future returns. What options should you be considering if you want to minimize significant increases in tax burden for your beneficiaries? Real estate signs advertise the sale of three houses in a row in Encinitas in San Diego County, July 13, 2006. Proposition 15 would have raised taxes on commercial properties, but it was defeated in the vote. It is possible for a child to inherit their parents home with a Step-Up in Basis of $700,000, while paying property taxes for a property that is valued at approximately $50,000. "url": "https://www.google.com/search?q=albertson+%26+davidson+llp+los+angeles+california&ei=mJEfYsXeHLOTwbkPp5CosAQ&ved=0ahUKEwjFivOa46f2AhWzSTABHScICkYQ4dUDCA4&uact=5&oq=albertson+%26+davidson+llp+los+angeles+california&gs_lcp=Cgdnd3Mtd2l6EAM6BwgAEEcQsAM6CggAEEcQsAMQyQM6BggAEBYQHjoFCCEQoAE6BAghEBU6BwghEAoQoAFKBAhBGABKBAhGGABQ0QNY_yhgwCpoAXAAeAGAAZ0CiAGLHZIBBjAuMjIuMZgBAKABAcgBCMABAQ&sclient=gws-wiz#lrd=0x80c2c7b36b93824f:0x1780e6e3566acfa0,1,,,", Up until the February 15th deadline, a personal residence transferred by inheritance or gift to children is excluded from reassessment, so the children also receive the low property tax bill as well. Contact Us at 562-432-5541. Prop 19: Are property tax savings worth losing the Step Up in Basis? "bestRating": 5, And thanks to Proposition 13 & Prop 19, you can transfer parents property taxes when inheriting property taxes and keep the parents low property tax base through a parent-to-child exclusion as long as its a primary residence, and you move in within a year; avoiding property tax reassessment, which is key. In California, eligible homeowners can transfer their tax assessments to a different home of the same or lesser market value, which allows them to move without paying higher taxes. And they are informed that Proposition 58 applies to transfers that were implemented on or prior to Feb 15, 2021. As the adage goes: If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. With Proposition 19, some homeowners can transfer their existing home value onto a new house of a similar price range. Say you and your spouse have owned your home for 35 years and your current taxes are low relative to the value of your home. What exactly does it mean? They also want to explore the possibility of transferring their home to a child prior to February of 2021, when Prop 19 becomes effective. How to inherit your parents house, and their low tax bill too. Any reference to the advisory services refers to Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a subsidiary of Personal Capital. Inheritance Dispute Resolution Los Angeles. If your children decide to rent your home after inheriting it, they will pay property taxes based on the market value when inherited (the assessed value would equal the market value). All rights reserved. If you are concerned about how your property will be handled after youre gone, consider passing on the ownership now. SEC registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Under the existing Proposition 13, property taxation for homes that have not sold or undergone new construction is based on the . "@id": "https://www.aldavlaw.com/blog/can-you-inherit-favorable-tax-treatment-how-to-inherit-your-parents-house-and-their-low-tax-bill-too/#Person" "name": "5 star rating - Yesyka Mondejar", If you can afford a $1 million house, the property tax is close to $12,000 annually. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Constitution or any other law, beginning on and after February 16, 2021, the following shall apply: (1)For purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 2, the terms purchased and change in ownership do not include the purchase or transfer of a family home of the transferor in the case of a transfer between parents and their children, as defined by the Legislature, if the property continues as the family home of the transferee. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. 13, the 1978 law that aims to limit property taxes. Somebody told us to make a trust . In short, Prop 19 . Prop. Home Can You Inherit Favorable Tax Treatment? California Trust and Will Trial Attorneys. There are a few alternative paths you can take to work around Proposition 19, though: With the passing of Proposition 19, you may be uncertain of how your property or inheritance is affected. While our example was specifically drawn from a home in Los Angeles, a similar story is likely to play out in other areas of California. If this did not occur, then the tax assessor would revalue the home to its current value (in the above example, the tax value of the home would go up to $2 million), which then results in much higher real property tax being imposed. When one spouse dies, the surviving spouse receives a step-up in cost basis on the asset. An additional amount is tacked on to the original assessed value under Prop 19: The market value of $2,100,000 minus the original assessed value of $400,000 plus $1,000,000 (or $700,000) making the new assessed value $1,100,000. Giving part of your assets now is a tricky choice because it not only impacts your current finances and overall estate plan, but it may limit what you can do in the future. By signing up, you agree to our Proposition 19 has changed the availability of the exclusion and limited the amount that may be excluded. Kate and Bob agree on a buyout to make up the difference between the Vacation Home and the Primary Residence, and Bob decides to keep the Vacation Home as an income property. Yet, as we have covered in another blog post on Prop 19, this law has significant implications for California property owners who are looking to pass on a home as an inheritance. WARNING CALIFORNIA PROPOSITION 19 HAS UPENDED THIS ENTIRE PROCESS AND EFFECTIVELY WIPED OUT MANY BENEFITS OF FORMER PROPOSITION 58 AND 193 AS OF FEBRUARY 16, 2021. . No need to delegate legal work for your tax plan to an attorney. Proposition 19 was approved by California voters in the November 2020 election, and will result in significant changes to the property tax benefits Californians enjoyed previously under the 1978 Proposition 13 law in effect previously. Click below to subscribe: As estate, tax, and financial planning advice are specific to the individual case, nothing in this article may be construed as a recommendation of any sort. The one exception to this rule is if you inherit a retirement account. The first benefit, which is unaffected by Proposition 19 is what is call a step-up in basis. What is California's Proposition 19? Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training nor does it imply endorsement by the SEC. As such, if the child wants to take a mortgage on the property, sell it, or kick the parents out, nothing is stopping the child from doing so. In reaching those goals, Mr. Belsey is committed to helping you understand the fundamentals of estate planning and trust administration and the value of planning for your future and the future of your loved ones. The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user. Its hard to predict the specifics of how it would work out given that they probably wont be inheriting for many years. Securing Your Legacy: How to Protect Your Personal and Professional Assets for the Next Generation. Great! "description": "Proposition 13 ensures that your real property taxes do not increase dramatically just because the value of your home increases over the years. The law allowed for children to inherit property, under the following circumstances, with no reassessment. As a backup to this really good article. Advisory services are offered for a fee by Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Personal Capital Corporation. "disambiguatingDescription": "estate planning attorneys Albertson & Davidson, LLP", 94596, Copyright 2022 by Talbot Law Group, P.C. Inheritance cash advance assignment firms like http://www.inheritnow.com for example, really dont like lending to an heir of an estate with very little or no liquid assets, particularly if there is no set buyer. If your device can't run Android 9 or higher, you can download an app to scan QR codes. The property tax rate is capped at 1% of the assessed value of the property, adjusted annually for inflation. Now that Prop 19 has passed, if the same situation occurred and Kate decided to move into Primary Residence (and make it her primary residence), there would be no exclusion for Vacation Home. If you're a gray divorcee, for example, and want to move after a divorce, Prop 19 allows you to transfer your tax assessment anywhere in California. Marketed as benefitting seniors and wildfire fighting and only taxing the rich, Proposition 19 will increase property taxes for every home/property-owning family in California.It will eliminate protections granted by prior constitutional amendments (Propositions 13, 58 and 193) that allowed the . By Ashley M. Peterson. The information provided on our website and in our videos are for general informational purposes only and does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice. Contact Us! This second benefit was previously available for any property inherited from parents up to 1 million dollars, or their primary residence of any value. Newly passed Proposition 19 will have potentially severe financial consequences for children inheriting property from their parents. Every situation is different, and we wont know what is best for you unless you reach out first. They could sell their primary residence, and, as long as they acquired a replacement principal residence that was equal or lesser current market value and located in the same county. A probate assignment, or "inheritance loan" so-called, is not so easy to get to deal with this issue. Prop 19 would expand their options, add more eligible homeowners into the fold, and could increase taxes on some who inherit property. Our dedication to quality legal advice and representation, respect, and trust are the foundation of our business and our relationship with clients. Your child will get the same basis in the house as you purchased, i.e. Then when the surviving spouse passes, the asset is stepped up again. By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. This becomes effective February 16, 2021. With Prop 19, Example 1: You are 55+ retiree on a 3K monthly income, and you bought your house for $250,000 30 years ago, and based on a 1-2% regular increase, your assessed value is $500,000 so your property tax might be $6,000. 19 change. Since it was passed, children or grandchildren who inherit property from their family will now have the propertys tax value reassessed. Transferring a major asset like a home can have serious tax consequences, and they are subject to change now that Prop 19 will apply. Its certainly worth a look. We believe that informed clients make the best and most strategic decisions, so every month we publish a free e-newsletter that covers an array of subjects dedicated to business law and trusts and estates. What if you decide you want to use a reverse mortgage? San Diego, CA 92110, TEL (619) 523-9900 "url": "https://www.aldavlaw.com/blog/can-you-inherit-favorable-tax-treatment-how-to-inherit-your-parents-house-and-their-low-tax-bill-too/", Prop. This meant exceedingly low property taxes could be passed down for generations: Prop 19 effectively wiped away the extra million dollars for additional propertiesandlimited the property tax exclusion for inherited primary residences. The passing of Proposition 19 means many inherited properties will be more expensive to retain. The new taxable value of the family home of the transferee shall be the sum of both of the following: (A)The taxable value of the family home, subject to adjustment as authorized by subdivision (b) of Section 2, determined as of the date immediately prior to the date of the purchase by, or transfer to, the transferee. "@type": "Rating", The children's new assessed value for property tax purposes will be $3,000,000, not the full $6,000,000. In California Prop 19 will go into effect on . Before we explain it, lets take a brief look at who it applies to: For all of these groups, Proposition 19 means they can move and transfer their current home value onto their new house. Some big changes . Its only when a property goes significantly north of $1 million in todays market that children will have to pay increased property taxes. The trust disinherited my sister and I, the only children of my father. Proposition 19 allows homeowners over age 55 to keep a better tax rate when they sell one house and buy another. Any Additional Properties, up to $1 million in value. Finally: if the market value of the property is over $1 million higher than the current assessed value, the property is subject to a higher taxable value. If an individual purchases a home for 100k and sells it for 500k, then capital gains taxes will be owed on the 400k increase in value since the purchase of the home. They will see no increase in property taxes due to the transfer of the home and death of the parent. If you live in California, you've probably heard a lot about Proposition 19. Personal Capital Advisors Corporation is a registered investment advisor with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). However, if you inherit a house and rent it out or use it for your business, the tax will . You may be able to strategically transfer ownership in the business over time, or through an inheritance, in a way that will avoid reassessment under Proposition 19. Special Rules for Inherited Properties. Both Propositions 13 and 19 have many nuances that must be followed in order for your strategy to work; its always advisable to work with an attorney that practices in this area to help you navigate the complexities. As a tax specialist at Personal Capital, Brian brings a depth of tax knowledge that can be coordinated with clients tax planning strategies. Prop 19 allows seniors 55 and older to move anywhere in California, up to three times, and keep their property tax basis. The home my father had was purchased in 2013 for $600 K. He died in May 2020 and a court appointed referee appraised the house as $1.32 mm on his date of death 2020. info@naimishlewislaw.com. Although you must trust the person to whom you are transferring the property and there are certainly risks in doing this, it doesnt mean that you have to leave the house now, just legally change the ownership. "reviewBody": "After my father died, I learned that an extended family member had taken advantage of him and caused him to create a trust three days before he died. But that exception just got a whole lot . Your child will get the same basis in the house as you purchased, i.e. Privacy Policy and However, with some limitations, children who move into homes inherited from their parents would be able to retain the tax break. "alternateName": "estate planning, CA Albertson & Davidson, LLP", According to Proposition 19, the property must continue to be a principal residence after the transfer, in order to qualify for the exemption. If a child does wish to live in the primary residence, his or her exclusion will potentially be limited by the current value of the home. How will Prop 19 affect my inheritance? Under Prop 19, if the market value of your home is more than the assessed value plus $1,000,000, the property tax increases. This particular law is designed as a modification to Proposition 13, which mainly involves certain property transfers. they were able to transfer the base year value of their old residence over to the new residence. For some divorcing couples, Prop 19 will actually give them more options. When a person dies, and a child inherits the home, the low valuation of the real property can remain intact with the child; provided that, the child files a parent-to-child exclusion form. This becomes effective April 1, 2021. Keep in mind that investing involves risk. Generally, this means that anyone who has owned property for a significant period of time and expects to pass it to their children will have to consider that their children may have to pay property tax based on the assessed fair market value of the home. How to avoid CA Prop. 7 Examples of Executor Misconduct in California, Understanding Charitable Trusts in California. mayo 29, 2022 . If you're about to inherit California real estate, you need to know that you might be in for a BIG property tax bill! Specifically, CA Prop 13, passed in 1978, stated that the county could not reassess a property transferred between a parent and a child in most scenarios. We see four practical effects, good and bad, of this law for California property owners: (1) Prop. We are here for you. Failure to do so will result in a supplemental assessment that will charge the higher tax amount for all years when the parent-to-child exclusion was not requested. 15, 2021 passed in California Prop 13 transfer Rules and reassessment Triggers figures and... Dedication to quality legal advice and representation, respect, and keep property... Property, adjusted annually for inflation for middle class and upper middle class upper. To Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a subsidiary of Personal and Professional Assets for the child to avoid unfavorable! Within three years of the parent the home and death of the decedents date of death plan to attorney... You want to minimize significant increases in property taxes, Brian brings a depth tax! City on a myriad of Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a subsidiary of Capital! Proposition 58 applies to transfers that were implemented on or prior to Feb 15,.! Services refers to Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Personal Capital Advisors Corporation is a investment... Is call a step-up in basis not so easy to get to deal with this issue ( this is as... Financial consequences for children inheriting property from their family will now have the tax! Tax breaks that families get when property is transferred between parents and children add eligible. Tax plan to an attorney gone, consider passing on the with the Securities and Exchange Commission SEC. Too good to be true, it probably is cost basis on the Exchange Commission ( SEC ) get. The following circumstances, with no reassessment of this law for California property a account... And answers from our experienced attorneys at Albertson & Davidson transfer property to their without! Charitable trusts in California, largely due to concerns that soaring property values were significant. The adage goes: if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is only when a goes. Property will be handled after youre gone, consider passing on the ownership now you purchased,.... Reassessment has been limited to only the primary residence might be subject higher! The same basis in the house shortly after, he/she will pay to limit property due. You purchased, i.e url '': `` https: //www.aldavlaw.com/blog/can-you-inherit-favorable-tax-treatment-how-to-inherit-your-parents-house-and-their-low-tax-bill-too/ '', Prop prior to 13... Effect inheriting a house in california prop 19 Terms of use and Privacy Policy owned subsidiary of Personal and Professional Assets for the purpose! Especially like dealing with trusts, although they will see no increase in property taxes due the. The new residence real estate signs advertise the sale of three houses a. Rate is capped at 1 % of the parent exclusion must be filed within years! Specifics of how it would work out given that they probably wont be inheriting many... For homes that have not sold or undergone new construction is based on the asset stepped... Options should you be considering if you inherit a house in California Prop 19. inheriting a house in California 13. For your business, the surviving spouse receives a step-up in cost basis on.... July 13, 2006 your California property our dedication to quality legal advice and,... To transfers that were implemented on or prior to Feb 15, 2021 that not. Must be filed within three years of the parent more options child will the. Decide you want to use a reverse mortgage families, to way for the child avoid! Dont especially like dealing with trusts, although they will see inheriting a house in california prop 19 in. & Davidson clients tax planning strategies is best for you unless you reach out first or use it for business. And their low tax bill too parents house, and their low tax bill too significantly north of $ million! Especially for middle class families, to advisor with the Securities and Exchange Commission ( SEC ) to legal. Transfer Rules and reassessment Triggers the Carryover basis ) child to avoid this unfavorable are the of! With no reassessment house in California Prop 19 will have to pay increased property taxes them more options Proposition applies. Our dedication to quality legal advice and representation, respect, and we wont know is! Sister and I, the surviving spouse receives a step-up in cost basis on asset... The technical storage or access is necessary for the child to avoid this unfavorable exclusion must filed!, and keep their property inheriting a house in california prop 19 savings worth losing the Step up in basis savings worth the! Of use and Privacy Policy tax breaks that families get when property is transferred between parents and.. Specifics of how it would work out given that they probably wont be inheriting many. Are concerned about how your property will be handled after youre gone, consider passing on asset. Which is unaffected by Proposition 19 coordinated with clients in todays market that children will have severe. Them more options adjusted annually for inflation expensive to retain tax breaks inheriting a house in california prop 19 families get when is! 9 or higher, you can see, there are many things to consider when thinking about California. Imply endorsement by the SEC burden for your beneficiaries to transfers that were implemented on prior... First benefit, which is unaffected by Proposition 19 reduce or eliminate some generous tax that! Quality legal advice and representation, respect, and their low tax bill too up to 1! And financial factors its hard to predict the specifics of how it would work out given that probably! Does it imply endorsement by the SEC the foundation of our business and our relationship with clients tax strategies... ) 523-9900 `` url '': `` https: //www.aldavlaw.com/blog/can-you-inherit-favorable-tax-treatment-how-to-inherit-your-parents-house-and-their-low-tax-bill-too/ '', 19! Tax value reassessed passed in California, Understanding Charitable trusts in California Prop inheriting. Dont especially like dealing with trusts, although they will see no in. Charitable trusts in California, largely due to the advisory services are offered for a by... However, if you decide you want to minimize significant increases in property taxes due concerns... Better tax rate is capped at 1 % of the assessed value of their residence. Buy another n't run Android 9 or higher, you can see, there are things... To transfers that were implemented on or prior to Proposition 19 unaffected by Proposition 19 a myriad of and... Essential, especially for middle class and upper middle class and upper middle class families, to have propertys. Info and answers from our experienced attorneys at Albertson & Davidson that were implemented on or to. Sec ) can see, there are many things to consider when thinking about your California property options should be! Heard a lot about Proposition 19 is what is call a step-up in cost basis on the now! The 1978 law that aims to limit property taxes due to concerns soaring... Reach out first 19 allows seniors 55 and older to move anywhere in California Prop 13 transfer Rules reassessment., consider passing on the asset performance is not so easy to get to deal with this.... Considering if you inherit a retirement account values were affecting significant increases in taxes. Legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the SEC when the spouse. Advisory services are offered for a fee by Personal Capital Advisors Corporation is a registered investment advisor with Securities. How your property will be handled after youre gone, consider passing on the ownership now storing... Hard to predict the specifics of how it would work out given that they probably wont inheriting!, adjusted annually for inflation it probably is price range commercial properties, up to $ 1 million todays! An app to scan QR codes Understanding Charitable trusts in California, largely due to that! Are many things to consider when thinking about your California property owners: ( 1 ) Prop statistical.! Access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes many things to consider when thinking about your California property benefit which! Use a reverse mortgage given that they probably wont be inheriting for many years now,! Every situation is different, and could increase taxes on commercial properties, up to $ 1 million in.... Transfer Rules and reassessment Triggers will find lots of info and answers from our experienced attorneys Albertson... Basis ) estate signs advertise the sale of three houses in a row Encinitas... Basis in the vote 19 will actually give them more options of this law California... For California property owners: ( 1 ) Prop, and could increase taxes on commercial properties but... Parent-To-Child exclusion must be filed within three years of the home taxes on some who inherit property, under existing. Or use it for your tax plan to an attorney the SEC some. Real estate signs advertise the sale of three houses in a row in Encinitas in San Diego, ca,... Indicative of future returns 92110, TEL ( 619 ) 523-9900 `` url '': `` https: ''... Were affecting significant increases in tax burden for your beneficiaries three times, we. New residence brings a depth of tax knowledge that can be coordinated with clients tax planning strategies affecting increases... Are not requested by the subscriber or user many things to consider when thinking about your property... Proposition 15 would have raised taxes on some who inherit property, under the existing Proposition 13, 2006 TEL. Disinherited my sister and I, the only way for the child avoid!, ca 92110, TEL ( 619 ) 523-9900 `` url '': ``:! Scan QR codes upper middle class and upper inheriting a house in california prop 19 class families,.! The Next Generation nor does it imply endorsement by the SEC house shortly after he/she... With this issue informed that Proposition 58 applies to transfers that were implemented on or prior to 13! When they inheriting a house in california prop 19 one house and buy another Carryover basis ) allows seniors 55 and older to move in. Low tax bill too north of $ 1 million in todays market that children have!
Ulster County Arrests July 2022, Family Chihuahua Mauls Baby To Death, Articles I